Why is it Critical to See a Psychiatrist or Psychiatric NP for Mental Health Medication?

September 1, 2022
anxious man being comforted by his Psychiatrist

A meeting with a psychiatrist for a diagnosis can be pretty helpful if you struggle to manage some aspects of your life. They can help with the diagnosis of numerous illnesses and disorders when you are having problems and are unsure of the cause.


It can be daunting to get medication for your mental health. But how can you be sure that you've been prescribed the right medications?


This issue is affecting many of us as around 40 million Americans have been taking psychiatric drugs. According to the Advisory report, one in six U.S. adults reported consuming more than one psychiatrist's drugs in 2013.


The American Psychological Association reports that American adults' consumption of psychiatric drugs increased by 22% between 2001 and 2010, and this figure is increasing further.


Brendan L. Smith wrote in the 2012 edition of APA's Monitor on Psychology Magazine that psychiatric drugs are beneficial tools for the medication of numerous mental health disorders, but inadequate prescription can cause serious harm. Being able to recognize when someone needs psychiatric help is critical, and several factors indicate a psychiatric evaluation is important.


But how can we trust that we're prescribed the right medication and the proper dosage for our mental health condition? Keep reading the article to learn.


Who can Prescribe Mental Health Medication?


First, let's take a look at who can legally prescribe medication. Mental Health America includes psychiatrists, psychiatric or mental health nurse practitioners, physician's assistants, or primary care physicians in the list of professionals.

 

You can also get a prescription from your general physician for mental health conditions and disorders, but remember that this may not always be your best option for your mental health care and care management treatment.


Getting Medication Without an Evaluation can be Risky.


Most people receive psychiatric medication without proper evaluation or diagnosis from physicians, psychiatrists, or mental health professionals.


Brendan L. Smith, in a report from 2011 by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, wrote, "Now patients often receive psychiatric medication without being diagnosed by a mental health professional." 

Psychiatric Services, the leading journal in mental health services, published a report in 2013 that 58% of adults who were prescribed psychiatric medication in 2009 had no psychiatric diagnosis during that year.


According to psychiatrist Victoria L Dunckley, M.D., "Prescribing drugs before proper mental health diagnosis can be very risky. In psychiatry, there is a lot of symptom overlap, which means that the same systems represent more than one disorder, making the diagnosis tricky and increasing the possibility of wrong medical prescription". 


APA's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder (DSM-5) has set the criteria for specific diagnosis consisting of descriptions, symptoms, and other criteria for diagnosing mental health disorders.

 

Get Your Medication from a Psychiatrist or NP


Just because a general physician can prescribe medication and you can do so without an in-depth diagnosis, it doesn't mean you should do it. It is usually preferable to have your medications managed by a psychiatrist or psychiatric nurse practitioner.


Generally speaking, basic care physicians lack the knowledge and time necessary to do a complete assessment and obtain an excellent psychiatric history.


On the other hand, psychiatrists and psychiatric nurse practitioners have medical training allowing them to diagnose, treat and prevent mental, emotional, and behavioral disorders, including anxiety disorders, bipolar disorders, Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), depression, personality disorders, etc. They prescribe mental health medications and other medical treatments.


Psychiatrists and Psychiatric NPs are medical professionals who order and perform a range of physical and psychological tests. They can rule out medical causes while detecting mental health issues using these tests, combined with discussions about symptoms, medical history, and family history.


Psychiatrists and Psychiatric NPs use criteria from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) published by the American Psychiatric Association to evaluate specific mental health issues.


Psychiatrists and Psychiatric NPs use a range of treatments, such as different types of psychotherapy, drugs, psychosocial interventions, and other treatments (such as electroconvulsive therapy, or ECT), depending on the needs of each patient.


A psychologist usually holds a doctoral degree, most frequently in clinical psychology, and has received considerable training in both clinical practice and research. Psychologists use psychotherapy to treat mental disorders; some have advanced training in psychological assessment and testing.

 

The benefits of seeing a psychiatrist or NP


There are a lot of benefits for you to start seeing a psychiatrist. Some of them are:


  • They offer an in-depth evaluation


Psychiatrists usually perform an assessment and a diagnosis, or both, before prescribing any drug. These experts have the training and experience to conduct evaluations and diagnoses.


  • They take a patient-focused approach


Psychiatrists are urged to use a client-centered approach. They are also urged to discuss their treatment choices with their patients, according to a report in a 2015 Social Science & Medicine research.

The study "analyzed how psychiatrists defend their mental treatment recommendations to clients" using field recordings of actual psychiatric appointments. The researchers found that psychiatrists utilize two distinct "accounts" (i.e., justifications) when prescribing medication. First, they tailor their recommendations to the client's needs and concerns, and Secondly, they base their recommendations on their professional experience.


  • They provide valuable insight


Psychiatrists provide patients with added insight into their mental health disorders or condition. Insight in this context means a patient's judgment of his illness. For example, a patient suffering from schizophrenia disorder may not realize that their delusions aren't real.


People experiencing medical conditions do not grasp the illness, but they are aware of their conditions and realize the value of receiving therapy. In contrast, people with psychiatric disorders frequently are unaware that anything is wrong. They don't believe they require assistance or think there is nothing that can be done to assist them.


Psychiatrists are fully aware of this, which is why they focus more on how psychiatric disorders affect the patient and what specific treatments may be better for them.


Patient insight must cover states of high internal emotion and low drive in the presence of frequently incorrect perceptions. By selecting the best meds for that particular patient, a psychiatrist will be able to develop a better treatment plan taking this into account.


You will also identify other benefits, including:


  • Necessary help to change your personal as well as professional life
  • To control and alleviate your emotions
  • To encounter your fears so you can come to terms with reality
  • To overcome traumatic experiences and to be able to solve personal issues with support and guidance
  • To develop trust with yourself and with others
  • To obtain an objective perspective and professional suggestions about your problems and figure out how to solve them
  • To return to a healthy lifestyle


Does Everyone Need Medication?


Not all patients require medicine to begin their treatment, which may need to be clarified, and it would depend on your issues and the therapist's assessment. The psychiatrist will provide you with enough knowledge about the medicine to enable you to make an informed decision regarding the dangers, advantages, and available treatments.


The expert will consult you to determine whether you require the medication and which type is best for you. On the other hand, you and your psychiatrist must choose the same course of action because, in the end, you will be the one to decide whether to take medication or not.


After evaluating and diagnosing you, an expert psychiatrist will also take time to explain the various treatments available, including those which don't require medication, for instance, cognitive behavioral therapy with a licensed therapist.


Your psychiatrist will identify the medication or medication combinations that are best for your treatment at this point. Your prescription will be reviewed each time you have an appointment and, if necessary, modified in terms of dosage or a new medication added for improved results.


The essential step to perceive the changes and improvements is your and your therapist's commitment.


When Should I See a Psychiatrist?


An honest self-evaluation of your symptoms and everyday events is frequently necessary to decide when to consult a psychiatrist.


 If you are having negative thoughts, lost and unable to see a way out, call a professional. You will soon see improvements in your life if you are consistent and responsible. You can solve your problems with the proper medication, guidance, and support. Psychiatrists are skilled professionals and have all the necessary elements for you to feel respected and safe during each appointment.


When it comes to your mental health condition, a complete evaluation and proper diagnosis from an in-person or online psychiatric provider such as Virtual Psychiatric Care is necessary.


Remember that having or seeking therapy for mental health illnesses is not shameful. The sooner you'll feel better sooner you'll get help and medication.


Final Thoughts


However, it can be overwhelming to recognize and seek help for a mental health condition; it's critical you do. A psychiatrist provides an accurate diagnosis and suggests treatment plans. They are experts in their field and have up-to-date knowledge on research, medication, and other treatment therapies that can benefit you. Your psychiatrist will help you understand the best treatment for you. 

A doctor is talking to a patient while holding a clipboard.
July 22, 2025
Curious about the difference between a psychiatrist and a psychiatric-mental health nurse practitioner (PMHNP)? Learn how their training, approach, and roles in mental health care compare.
Man stressed from work, unemployment, anxiety, heartbroken and depression
July 22, 2025
We’ve all had a moment where we Googled a headache and convinced ourselves it was a brain tumor. (Don’t worry—you’re not alone.) But when those worries become a pattern, not just a panic moment, you may be dealing with health anxiety. Let’s break it down: What is healthy anxiety? How does it differ from unhealthy worrying? And how do you know if your brain is trying to keep you safe—or just keeping you stuck? 😷 What Is Healthy Anxiety? Healthy anxiety is a normal response that alerts you to potential danger and encourages you to take care of yourself. But when anxiety turns excessive and becomes persistent fear about having—or developing—a serious illness, it can cross into the territory of unhealthy worrying. Even when tests come back normal, the worry doesn’t let up. It’s not dramatic or attention-seeking—it’s a real mental health experience. πŸ” How Health Anxiety Shows Up It’s not always dramatic or obvious. It can be quiet, persistent, and exhausting. Here’s what it might look like: You Google symptoms obsessively (even at 2 a.m.) You avoid doctors *or* visit them constantly You can’t stop scanning your body for signs something is wrong You feel brief relief after tests—but the worry returns quickly You ask friends or family repeatedly, “Do you think this is serious?” You can’t focus on other things when a symptom appears You struggle to believe medical reassurance for long πŸ’­ What’s the Difference Between Healthy Anxiety & Unhealthy Worry? We all worry about our health sometimes—it’s part of being human. But here’s the difference: Normal Health Concern: Comes and goes with context (e.g., cold symptoms) Trusts medical reassurance Can accept uncertainty Doesn’t interfere with daily life Unhealthy Worry: Persistent and intrusive Doubts medical reassurance, seeks it repeatedly Feels compulsive need for certainty Disrupts sleep, focus, and relationships 🧠 Why It Happens Health anxiety can stem from: Childhood illness (yours or a loved one’s) Trauma or unpredictable environments Medical trauma or misdiagnosis Perfectionism and fear of “losing control” A deep belief that “if I worry enough, I can prevent something bad” The brain thinks worry = protection. But in reality? Chronic worry wears you down and makes life smaller. πŸŒͺ️ Unhealthy Worrying: The Spiral Ever had this kind of moment? You feel a slight chest twinge → You Google “chest pain” → You see words like “heart attack” → Your heart really starts racing → You interpret that as a symptom, not anxiety → You spiral into panic. That’s the vicious cycle: body sensation → worry → anxiety → more sensations → more worry. It’s not your fault. It’s a loop your brain learned—and you can learn to break it. 🧘 What Actually Helps You don’t have to live stuck in the cycle. Real healing starts with understanding and gentle interruption of the patterns. Tools that help: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): challenges anxious thoughts with facts Mindfulness & somatic work: reconnects you with the present moment Limit Googling and set boundaries with symptom-checking Self-compassion practices: remind your brain you’re safe Therapy or psychiatric care: addresses deeper roots of the anxiety ❀️ You’re Not Alone—And There Is Hope Health anxiety is exhausting, but it is treatable. At Virtual Psychiatric Care, we help people unravel anxious thinking, regulate their nervous systems, and live with more peace—without becoming a worrier about worrying. Your brain might be trying to protect you, but your soul deserves peace, too. Follow us on Instagram @virtual.psychiatric.care for more real talk on anxiety, healing, and hope. πŸ“² Reach out if you’d like to talk to someone about your health anxiety. We’re here. You’re safe. You can heal.
Young woman talking with psychotherapist
July 22, 2025
Ever found yourself totally tongue-tied during an argument? Or maybe you've said way too much to avoid someone being mad at you? Maybe your heart raced just walking into a room? Guess what—your brain isn’t broken, it’s trying to protect you. Welcome to the world of trauma responses, also known as the 5 Fs: Fight, Flight, Freeze, Fawn, and Flop. These are survival responses hardwired into your nervous system. When your brain senses danger—real or imagined—it picks a strategy to keep you safe. Let’s break them down, with fun, real-life examples! πŸ₯Š Fight: "Let’s throw down!" What it looks like: You gear up to confront the threat head-on. Your heart pounds, adrenaline kicks in, and suddenly you’re channeling your inner superhero—or maybe your inner Hulk. Everyday example: Someone cuts in front of you in line and your first instinct is to say something. You raise your voice, your chest tightens, and you're ready to make sure justice is served—even if it's just at Starbucks. Trauma twist: If you grew up in chaos, 'fighting' may have been your only way to feel powerful or in control. πŸƒ‍♀️ Flight: "I gotta get outta here!" What it looks like: You want to escape—literally or mentally. Your legs get jittery, your eyes dart around the room, your mind is already looking for the nearest exit sign (even if it's just closing the Zoom tab). Everyday example: You're in a meeting and your boss asks you to speak off the cuff. Suddenly, your stomach drops, and all you can think is, “How fast can I fake a bathroom emergency?” Trauma twist: Flight responses are common in people who were constantly overwhelmed or needed to 'escape' emotionally growing up. 🧊 Freeze: "If I stay still, maybe it’ll go away." What it looks like: You shut down, go blank, or mentally disconnect. It’s like your body hits pause while your brain spirals. Everyday example: You’re confronted with unexpected bad news and your mind goes totally blank. You don’t cry. You don’t move. You just… stare. Trauma twist: Freeze often shows up when we feel powerless—like we did as children when big things happened and we couldn’t fight or flee. 🫢 Fawn: "Let me make you happy so I stay safe." What it looks like: You become super-pleasing, overly accommodating, and hyper-focused on someone else's needs—often at the expense of your own. Everyday example: You’re upset with your partner, but instead of sharing how you feel, you offer to cook dinner, rub their shoulders, and ask them how they’re feeling. Your needs go in the trash. Trauma twist: Fawning often stems from growing up in homes where love was conditional, and keeping the peace meant staying emotionally “safe.” πŸͺ΅ Flop: "I'm done. I can't even." What it looks like: You collapse mentally or physically. It’s beyond freeze—it’s like your nervous system just pulls the plug. Everyday example: After days of stress, you lie in bed staring at the ceiling, unable to move. You're not asleep. You're not scrolling. You're just… offline. Trauma twist: Flop is often seen in people who’ve experienced prolonged or severe trauma. It’s the body’s final shut-off when nothing else works. 🌱 Why it matters Understanding your trauma responses can help you: Recognize your patterns Respond with compassion instead of self-judgment Begin healing with the help of supportive tools, therapy, or trauma-informed care You're not "too much" or "too sensitive." Your nervous system is just doing its job—sometimes a little too well. 🧘‍♀️ What can help? If you find yourself stuck in a trauma response often, you’re not alone—and you’re not broken. Modalities like EMDR, somatic therapy, and compassionate coaching can help bring your nervous system back into balance. At Virtual Psychiatric Care, we support people just like you—navigating stress, healing trauma, and building emotional resilience one breath, one insight, one moment at a time. Follow us on Instagram @virtual.psychiatric.care for more brain-friendly, heart-centered mental health tips. πŸ§ πŸ’› You’ve got this—and we’ve got you. ο»Ώ
midlife-transformations
By Pascale Kidane April 10, 2025
Discover why it’s never too late to begin your healing journey. Whether you're in your 40s, 50s, or beyond, this post explores the realities of midlife challenges including rising rates of depression, anxiety, and substance use and offers compassionate, practical steps to reclaim your vitality and joy. Embrace self-compassion, seek support, and learn how small daily actions can lead to profound transformation at any stage of life.
A woman is sitting on a couch looking out a window.
By Logical Position March 6, 2025
We will explore what resilience truly means and how it impacts your emotional well-being. We’ll delve into the science behind resilience, share evidence-based techniques for enhancing it, and provide actionable steps you can implement today. Ready to cultivate a mindset that thrives even in tough times? Let’s dive in!
ways-to-build-a-deeper-connection-with-your-partner
By Pascale Kidane February 6, 2025
Building a deeper connection is not just about romance; it’s about friendship, trust, and support. Whether you're navigating the early stages of love or you've been together for years, there are always opportunities to strengthen your bond. So let’s dive into some effective strategies that can help you grow closer with your partner, ensuring both of you feel valued and understood in this beautiful journey called love.
ways-to-improve-your-mental-health
By Logical Position January 6, 2025
Our mental well-being shapes how we experience life. It influences our relationships, productivity, and overall happiness. This year, why not make resolutions that enrich your mind and spirit? Let’s explore some meaningful ways to enhance your mental health in 2025. Embrace the journey towards feeling better about yourself and your world!
A woman is sitting on a couch holding a cup of coffee.
By Pascale Kidane December 3, 2024
Holiday gatherings can be a mix of joy and stress, with opportunities to connect with loved ones and moments that challenge our patience and emotional boundaries. In this guide, we explore practical strategies to deepen meaningful connections with family while maintaining your mental health. Learn how to set clear boundaries, navigate tricky conversations, and stay grounded amidst potential triggers.
understanding-five-fs-of-trauma
By Pascale Kidane October 31, 2024
Explore the complex world of trauma responses and discover the “Five F’s”: Fight, Flight, Freeze, Fawn, and Flop. This article breaks down each reaction, providing insight into how they function as survival mechanisms and affect trauma survivors. Recognizing these responses not only fosters empathy and understanding but also opens pathways for healing. Dive into this essential guide to understand trauma's impact and gain a new perspective on resilience, personal growth, and supporting others on their journey. Join us in this conversation about mental health,
complex-ptsd
By Pascale Kidane September 24, 2024
We will delve into the intricacies of Complex PTSD—its signs and symptoms, possible causes, effective treatment options available today